Skip to content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Castra Prime

Which Players Have Earned a Spot in Troy Deeney's Top-Flight Weekly Best XI?

Following every set of Premier League fixtures during the current campaign, BBC soccer expert Troy Deeney will give you his team and boss of the week.

Here are the most recent selections. Do you agree? Share your opinions.

The Last Line of Defense

Jordan Pickford (Everton): A pivotal incident in the Toffees' 3-0 victory against Chelsea came from his brilliant stop to keep out Enzo Fernandez. Pickford has come up pretty big in key instances for his club throughout the campaign and, hopefully, he maintains this form for England in the summer World Cup. A week ago, he made a significant error versus Arsenal but he has picked himself up again to deliver for the Toffees.

The Backline

Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest): It was a huge must-win fixture for Forest away at Tottenham, with Premier League status hanging in the balance for each team. And Williams delivered a tremendous performance to guide his side get a crucial victory in the battle against the drop. He bagged a pair of assists, producing when it was needed most.

Matty Cash (Aston Villa): It seemed that West Ham posed a significant danger in attack but Cash was solid and kept things together for Villa. He managed to just keeping the play moving. He offered a lot going forward and simultaneously snuff out anything and everything the Hammers attempted in attack.

James Tarkowski (Everton): It constituted a further assured performance from the Toffees defender. He exhibited his composure and control, and was always where he needed to be. He made key challenges when required and, crucially, served as a steadying influence in their rearguard. How Chelsea must wish for a central defender with that kind of determination, particularly given the uncertain defensive displays they have exhibited at times.

Central Park

Chris Rigg (Sunderland): It amounted to a steady display from Rigg in a memorable Tyne-Wear derby. He did not do anything extraordinary against Newcastle but he executed all his duties exceptionally competently. With Rigg, you know what you are getting from him.

James Garner (Everton): He easily could have relaxed after receiving a call-up to the Three Lions team recently. But instead, he cracked on and delivered a great display. It came in the form of a exquisite pass from him to Beto for Everton's opener. From my time with him at Watford, I know he's synonymous with high energy and strong challenges. He possesses all the attributes and I am confident he performs for England to play his way into that World Cup final roster.

John McGinn (Aston Villa): He's their skipper, leader and heartbeat. It's been a pair of huge showings in the space of a week from him. Villa can be considered a respectable side. But McGinn elevates them to a top one. If they are going to secure the top five and challenge for the European title, they will need him to keep producing at this standard.

Harry Wilson (Fulham): He has cultivated a habit of scoring crucial strikes and he repeated the trick again this week. I question how the club can possibly find a replacement if he opts to leave. They are unlikely to spend a fortune on a player with what he offers. They need him to put pen to paper on a renewal as he is a extremely crucial component of that Cottagers set-up.

The Attack

Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United): It seems as though the Portugal playmaker is turning into a staple in the weekly best XI. You simply have to put him in once again following a further goal, and also causing the James Hill own goal. How long will United remain average and retain his services before he decides it is the right moment to depart the club?

Beto (Everton): This week, we have two forwards who are at very different points in their professional journey. I am uncertain Beto is a permanent solution for the Merseyside club's goalscoring woes, but manager David Moyes is getting the best out of him right now. It is notable considering how subpar he was in the initial months.

Danny Welbeck (Brighton): He was overlooked by Thomas Tuchel once more for the England team, at a point when they need cover to skipper Harry Kane. But Welbeck kept on produce for the Albion with a two goals, to defeat reigning champions Liverpool, and bring his tally to 12 goals for the campaign.

The Dugout Doyen

David Moyes (Everton): The game between Everton and Chelsea was a perfect example of traditional against modern. Chelsea's manager Liam Rosenior is continuing to establish himself at the start of his managerial career but Moyes devised a impeccable tactical plan to secure a convincing win. The Toffees were more assertive and stronger in all departments of the game and it was a massive win for them.

Do you agree with Troy's selections? Which players would make up your Team of the Week? Have your say.

KR
About the author

Kevin Richards

Elara Vance is a tech journalist and digital strategist with over a decade of experience covering emerging technologies and their impact on industries.

Castra Prime

Type to search articles.